Posts Tagged With: #God

Reposting from 2008: My view of “God” as it has evolved

Rakaposhi Mountain (7,788 m./ 25,550 ft.), viewed from Karakoram Highway, Gilgit-Baltistan (formerly Northern Areas), Pakistan, August 1985

I’m reposting this from 18 years ago as I find my view of “God” has hardly changed (evolved) since then, and I see no need to revise it:

Diary entry 26 April 2008:

Recapitulation of my ideas about god: What monotheists refer to as “God” is — to me — universal consciousness, the cosmos as a whole, the “sum” of all consciousness. God is in everything and everything is god. We humans are the highest level of consciousness on this planet earth — as far as we know — and we represent the highest level of the evolution of god here. On our small “island” in the cosmos god evolves through us, changes through us. If our “island” the earth is unique in this sense, then we humans are the spearhead of the evolution of god itself. God is not in any way greater than the cosmos and did not “create” it, and cannot exist separately from this cosmos. In fact, if we are unique — which seems unlikely if the cosmos is as we perceive it (see my post below: “the universe and us”), though certainly not impossible — then god is dependent on us to a great extent.

God has a “personality” of its own, and each one of us humans — and every other intelligent being that may exist elsewhere — represents an aspect of the “personality” of god. Each one of us reflects a facet of god’s nature.

If the cosmos itself “emerged” in some way through a Big Bang or something like it, then god was the internal essence that “emerged” with it, as did what we know as the laws of nature. The cosmos was not “created” based on any design but emerged and evolved through a process of trial and error, “guided” by god’s evolving intelligence based on the organization of memory. The emergence of life on earth and its evolution was also “guided” in this way by god. Humankind is a product of this evolution, taking consciousness to the highest level known so far on earth.

I believe god inspired man to create religions, spiritual teachings, etc., because it wanted to find a way to guide or even control humankind.

(More on 29 April 2008): This is also the reason why humans and just about everything else tends toward forming hierarchies and pecking orders. God needs hierarchical organization in order to be able to exploit and control “created” beings. And what we have come to regard as “good” and “evil” are just different ways of looking at things from the larger perspective of god. God has traditionally favored the strong, the top of any pecking order hierarchy, because he draws the greatest pleasure from that type of organization of both living beings and inanimate reflections of his consciousness. Is god, then, like a human in his feelings and behavior? I say, absolutely, yes: at least on this earth, our tiny part of the cosmos (=>“the universe and us” and “the end of religion” below), god cannot be otherwise, because we are this way — we reflect god’s nature and god is no greater than us as a collective, and no better.

More to come …

Here are my answers to two questions about the post above:

It is still difficult for anyone to imagine that god is just as “evil” as he is “good.” I think that is the case. My point is that god has encouraged both in humankind and has enjoyed setting one against the other, using hierarchies to form opposing groups centered on rival leaders. But god evolves and changes through us, as I have emphasized. And despite appearances to the contrary I believe we are very slowly moving towards a better world with less conflict and violence. Perhaps I am naïve, but I am quite sure that god cannot change the world to good. We can. There is no hope for us if we do not believe in humankind. God and the natural world has no meaning without us or some beings like us — it might as well not exist at all.

=====

By hierarchies I mean hierarchical-type organization as such, and what is known as “pecking orders” in particular — where the strong, wily (cunning) and/or violent generally dominate the weak. It is dominance by one or a few over others — especially systematic dominance. But it also includes implicit hierarchies where, for example, many people follow a spiritual leader (say, Jesus), who then dominates not by force but by love (if you can use that word in this sense) or the power of inspiration. God encompasses both great beauty, goodness and gentleness as well as their counterparts ugliness, evil and violence — just like we do. It is not that I am making god seem human but rather that I believe we humans are simply a full reflection of god: here on earth we represent the spearhead of god’s evolution, the highest point of consciousness that god itself (or him/herself) has reached. God cannot be different from us here – that is, from humankind as a whole.

There is no “absolute,” no “perfection”

November 2007 diary entry:

I continue to believe that we — humankind — must outgrow religion and all of the things that have divided us in such a way as to lead to war. All of our religions, which have been the foundations of civilizations, have tended to divide us because they have led us to use force against each other in the name of a god or gods. There are always “chosen” ones, favorites, or the “good” in religion as opposed to the others, the “bad” or “evil.” I do believe in an ideal of “goodness,” which we have been developing. There is no absolute “good.” There is no absolute anything at all. We are striving towards a goal that can never be reached — but which is nonetheless a worthy goal. Our understanding of this goal, this imaginary and forever unreachable “absolute” goodness, is evolving, and so is our ability to put this understanding into practice. But we must come to realize that the universal consciousness, the fundamental essence of the cosmos that we like to call “God,” is in itself neither good nor evil, and cannot move our world towards goodness without our help. — We have to begin by thinking and feeling as “we,” “us,” including all humankind; and beyond that all living beings, to a lesser extent.

The Biggest Lie (from a post originally written in July 2010)


We have been cheated, in a way. We have been living with a big lie: God. – But we have willingly participated. The lie is our lie, too. We have been happy to be deceived by God, because it is comforting to believe in a great supernatural power that is on the “good” side – which is always our side, because no one believes they are bad. Even the worst criminals and mass murderers believe they are “good.” They may admit mistakes – like most everybody does – but they always believe they are fundamentally “good.” However, the “good” can really exist only if there is also an opposing “evil.” We do believe in an “evil” but it is always someone else – just like God wants us to see “evil” as something entirely separate from him.

Yes, we are all part of this deception or self-deception. We participate willingly, most of the time. – But then we cannot separate from this God and his deception. This God leaves us some breathing space, some room for maneuver, some space for us to think for ourselves, because he wants us to grow, to improve, and he grows with us, improves with us – through us.

We are, all of us humans without exception, part of this God. We are really, ultimately, one. The whole cosmos is one, but we and any other intelligent beings that may exist are the most important elements of this one. The one, as I have said again and again, grows with us and through us.

I think perhaps the Buddhists have the deepest understanding of this oneness, this monism, this interdependence. The accounts of Buddhists I have read – such as those of the French Buddhist monk Matthieu Ricard – give me the impression that they have a much better and clearer understanding of the importance of oneness and interdependence than any Christians I have met, including the Moonies. Moon’s teaching has many good points, for sure, but I regard it as deficient in the sense of explaining the real God, and misleading. I think Moon himself does not want to acknowledge the fact that God has deceived us by making us believe in an “evil” that is not of him. Moon’s interests are better served if he just ignores this – and I tend to believe he knows that very well. This would be the element of hypocrisy in Moon that I feel has been touched on indirectly by Nansook Hong, the ex-wife of his now-late son Hyo Jin.
Of course, it is clear that – ultimately – we will have to work with God, no matter how much he has deceived us. We are inalienable parts of him and he is totally in each one of us. We are really one. My contention is only that we have to grow up to be aware of the reality of God – not the fantasy we have believed in for so long. – And the reason we have to grow up this way – with this understanding – is that it is the only way God can continue to evolve – and, indeed, grow himself. As I have insisted many times before: God evolves through us (and any other beings at the highest levels of consciousness) – he grows through us…

Categories: Thoughts | Tags: , , , , | Leave a comment

On Nature and God – and myself

Cyprus Troodos Mountains northeast of 1,950-m (6,400-ft) Mt.Olympus / Khionistra, March 1987
(picture taken with cheap Yashica fixed-focus camera)

From my diary Tuesday 4 July 2023:

Today, as I was in the forest up the hill behind our house with our dog Hana, I thought of my relationship with nature – our natural environment – and God.

There was a time, in 1974-75, when I became convinced that humankind could only survive if we destroyed our present world civilization – in a nuclear war, for example – and returned to a Stone Age existence in nature to start a new history, hopefully without making the mistakes I thought had led us down our disastrous path.

I wanted to try to become one of the survivors of such a nuclear war, which I expected to take place around 1979 (no idea how I came up with that time frame). This is why I went to America, to try to survive in nature on my own – as a test. If I survived in the woods of British Columbia/Canada for at least a year, becoming completely attuned to nature, I wanted to travel south to Patagonia, which I thought would be spared most of the deadly fallout caused by a central nuclear war since the vast majority of likely targets were in the northern hemisphere.

Of course, I met the “Moonies” (then known as the Unification Church, founded by the Korean Sun Myung Moon) in New York on my way to Canada and decided to join them.

When I took a “vacation” from the Moonies eight months later in November 1975 and hitch-hiked to California ( see https://erwinlux.com/2006/12/09/memory-of-california-thanksgiving-1975/ ), I wanted to try again to go to the woods in British Columbia. But I got stuck in Sacramento, where I tried unsuccessfully to hitch-hike north on Interstate Highway 5 for more than 2 days, sleeping among some bushes near the access ramp.

After some adventures over the next few days I gave up and returned to the Unification Church in Berkeley on Thanksgiving Day (among other things I had been robbed of almost all my possessions earlier that same day).

During the years I lived in Cyprus (1983-87 and 1990-91) I came closer to nature than ever before or since.

In the summer of 1984, about a year and a half after I moved to Nicosia, the capital of Cyprus, I started hiking in the Troodos Mountains, almost always alone. Walking through those mountains and later sleeping many nights outside under the stars (without a tent) was the most exhilarating activity I had ever experienced.

I thought I might finally meet God there, meaning the God I had learned about from the Bible, the Catholic teachings I absorbed in my youth, the very strict monotheistic concept of Islam I had encountered in the Middle East in 1972-73, and the idea of a long-suffering but loving Heavenly Parent promoted by the Moon church in its Divine Principle.

I never did meet that God, though I always tried to be open to Him/Her/It.

I now believe there is no such God in nature.

To me, the highest expression I can see of a God is in us humans – and it is nothing like the perfect, unchanging, all-knowing deity postulated by all of the monotheistic religions.

This God encompasses great beauty, goodness, love, empathy, magnanimity, compassion, intelligence, wisdom, and so on, but also their opposites, ugliness, evil, hatred, stupidity, selfishness, etc.

This God is evolving, changing, learning through us and with us, humans, at least in this tiny part of the universe, our Earth. I think this is the single most important insight I have found in my life, so far.

My first serious doubts about God -1994

The end of religion

Escape from God ….?

Father figure, and the inner voice

Cyprus Troodos Mountains: Sunset above clouds on Madari ridge, May 1985
(picture taken with cheap Yashica fixed-focus camera)

Diary, Sunday 19 February 2023:

It’s time to write about deeper things. … Who am I, really? Where do I stand? What do I believe?

The world is a mess in so many ways. It’s a mess mostly caused by the so-called “western” powers and their vassals and quislings in other countries.

I have left the ideology of Sun Myung Moon behind but I cannot replace it with another. I don’t want to adhere to any ideology. In a way I have one of my own, but it’s not elaborate at all and could not actually be called an ideology. There is too much vagueness and too much uncertainty.

There is just too much I simply don’t know.

It was comforting to have a ready-made ideology, to adhere to certain beliefs that somebody else had cooked up for me.

It took me several years to free myself of that belief system. There was a big gap left when I finally ditched it. I have found very few ideas that could help me plug that gap. After all, I followed Moon’s ideology for more than 20 years, and I cannot deny that it left a deep impression.

Also, I am reminded of it often because my wife remains a committed believer and insists that I go through at least some of the motions to go along with her. Doing this doesn’t hurt me, so I have no excuse to refuse. But I do feel just a little bit hypocritical. More important, however, is my strong desire to avoid friction, and even more so, confrontation over our different beliefs or ideas.

We both believe in a God. But my idea of God is very different from hers. She believes in the traditional God, the creator of all and “heavenly parent” of us humans.

To me, God is its own creation, and we humans are the best proof of its existence because we are at least in part what you could call the very mind of God. Without us and perhaps others like us in the cosmos, God would not have a fully developed mind that can explore the creation – which is basically God’s body. Yes, I think we are the mind of God, or at least an important part of it.

There are forms of consciousness at every level below us, and the cosmos as a whole is conscious. But we are the highest level we know in our tiny part of the universe, and thus we are part of the evolving mind of God.

So, what can I do with this wild idea? Nothing, really. I can think about it, and I have done less of that than most who read these lines might imagine. I can write about it here. It doesn’t serve me much in my life at all.

Nonetheless it feels to me much more authentic than anything I learned from Moon and the Moonies, which I always regarded as somehow artificial. It was something I had decided to impose on myself, both because it seemed to make a degree of sense and it helped me to connect with other people.

I never made any really close friends among my fellow Moonies, though. Of course, I didn’t have any close friends before either, even though I was 24 years old when I first encountered the Moon movement in the USA.

Maybe I am just too strange, too weird to be able to forge close friendships. …

View from my former ‘bedroom’ under a juniper tree on Troodos summit, Cyprus. Photo Oct. 2016

Categories: Thoughts | Tags: , , , , | 3 Comments

Brief account of my experiences in the Unification Church – now Family Federation -etc.

Unification Church members gathering at Tarrytown upstate New York in early 1975.

Adapted from a story originally written for the Facebook group Unification Church under the Microscope (*)


I’m from Luxembourg but I met and joined the Unification Church in the United States – twice, in 1975. The first time was during its teaching workshops in Barrytown (on the Hudson River in upstate New York, later the site of the Unification Theological Seminary) that spring, where I went through 3-, 7-, 21- and 40-day programs and also saw Moon (Sun Myung Moon – the Korean church/cult founder who died in 2012 and whose followers regard him and his still active wife Hak Ja Han as “the True Parents of humankind” representing God on Earth) for the first time. I must say he didn’t make a good first impression because to me he seemed terribly arrogant. I was mostly impressed with his “Divine Principle” teaching and the friendliness of a majority of the members, which is why I stayed in the movement.


In the summer I worked in Boston for a few weeks with a group from Barrytown led by Henry S. to restore a basement apartment that we later used as a witnessing center.


Peter S. (a member of that FB group at the time I wrote this) was my central figure for a short time at 4 W 43rd St. (the church headquarters in New York City) under Neil Salonen (then-president of the American church) in the fall of 1975. During that time I traveled a couple of times with Larry O. in a big truck down to the Sophie Mae factory in Atlanta to pick up loads of peanut brittle, which we dropped off for Mobile Fundraising Teams (church members who move from town to town selling various items door-to-door or in parking lots or bars to raise money for a “good cause” – the church) in the Carolinas, the Virginias, Tennessee, Kentucky, Ohio and Pennsylvania. Later I worked for a few weeks with Ron P. and Toni M. at the Going-Up Press printshop in Washington DC under its director George E.


After telling everyone I needed a break I left the job and the Washington DC branch of the church on Veterans Day (11 Nov.), and hitch-hiked down to Durham/North Carolina, then west along Interstate 40 all the way to California, sleeping under highway bridges a couple of nights. I briefly visited Brad B., a member friend who had quit, in San Rafael/Marin County, then tried for a few days hitch-hiking north from Sacramento, sleeping in bushes.


Later I rode freight trains with a hobo I met at a Sacramento soup kitchen but didn’t get very far. He was badly hurt on one train and I took him to a clinic (27 Nov.), then I was robbed near Livermore of all my meager possessions, and finally I was invited to a free Thanksgiving dinner in a house near University of California Berkeley campus by two “students” who said they belonged to a local “Creative Community Project” organization. I recognized quickly enough that it was the Unification Church by another name, but by that time I was ready to rejoin the fold anyway.


After a few weeks attending Divine Principle workshops and working in their garden at Boonville, and a few more mostly spent “witnessing” (proselytizing mostly young tourists) at Fisherman’s Wharf / San Francisco with Matthew Morrison I was sent east in a bus with many new recruits. Then came Moon’s big religious rallies at Yankee Stadium in New York in June 1976 and at the Washington Monument that September, and before the end of that US Bicentennial year (1776-1976) I became part of the editorial staff of our new daily The News World in New York City. At first I worked briefly in the National Department with Josette S., and then I was transferred to International under, first, Hal McK., then Robin K. and finally Betsy O.


I might mention here that I was an illegal alien the whole time I was in the US, never qualified to get a “green card” residence permit.


I pressured my bosses, publisher Mike W. and chief editor John D., to let me go to Bangkok, Thailand as correspondent, and after some time they agreed but told me I had to pay for the trip and most expenses from my own pocket.


In July 1979 I went home to Luxembourg to make some money working with local church members. In October I took the trans-Siberian train across the Soviet Union (from Luxembourg to Nakhodka, a journey of well over 11,000 kilometers on trains in 11 days, stopping overnight only in Moscow and Khabarovsk on the way), then a Soviet ferryboat through a typhoon in the Pacific to Yokohama, where I arrived exactly two weeks after leaving my country (6-20 October), followed by another two weeks traveling in Japan with my “spiritual mother” — a Japanese lady who had introduced me to the church in New York and who had invited me to visit her in Tokyo (her husband had been one of the first followers of Moon in Japan in the early 1960s – they are both deceased now).


In early November I went to Bangkok to try to work as correspondent. I didn’t manage to get a work permit and the high spiritual atmosphere in the local church center (I didn’t have enough money to afford a place of my own) was not at all conducive to journalistic work.


In New York, Mike W., John D. and others left their jobs and the church during that time, and the paper was in trouble — so in early 1980 after three months in Thailand I was called back.


Over the following two years I spent another 18 months working for The News World in NYC and several months in Luxembourg or traveling in Europe on my own, once spending 3 days in prison in Czechoslovakia in March 1982 because I was found in possession of “anti-Soviet” literature and documentation on nuclear weapons. My last time in the US was March-June 1982 when I did research for Russian émigré author Lev Navrozov in NYC.


— I’m telling you all this only so that you can see I was nothing at all like a model member. I was always more or less on the fringes of the movement, even though I believed in Divine Principle, True Parents and all that, and was deeply troubled by my own inability to completely “submit” (=this word always reminds me of the meaning of Islam; my few weeks as a practising Muslim in the Middle East in 1972-73, when I performed the full Haj pilgrimage to Mecca and Medina, had left a lasting impression).


Despite my status as a sort of loose member I was strongly urged by many friends and former central figures to participate in a matching (of couples by Moon himself for an arranged marriage – one of his many publicity-seeking mass weddings) in Seoul in October 1982, and this is where I had my one and only close encounter with Moon himself.


In the school of the Little Angels (a children’s singing and dancing troupe founded by Moon to charm world leaders, and whose large hall was crammed this time with men and women members waiting to meet their matches) he asked Western men who wanted to be matched with Oriental women to come forward. I was one of several dozen or more who did so.


After matching a few others he reached over somebody else’s shoulder, gently took me by the chin and – to my great surprise – asked me directly in English why I wanted an Oriental wife. I said I thought it was more interesting and I could learn more. He seemed to like my answer, then he asked where I worked and where I was from, and after hearing my answers he took me along a row of Oriental women and chose my wife, who is Japanese.


I realized later that I was chosen for the “Blessing” not because I was a good member or ready but simply because they needed to try to get as close to 6,000 couples together as possible. So bodies were needed to fill the quota.


Later I helped to start the weekly newspaper Middle East Times in Cyprus and worked there and in Greece for a few years while my wife worked in one of the church’s secret accounting offices in Japan and also went out fundraising (street selling) there.
I didn’t see my wife again until almost 4 years later, and then only for a week when we went to Luxembourg to meet my parents. In 1987 we got legally married in Japan but did not stay together as I took up an assignment as correspondent in Pakistan. We only started our family in 1988 when I returned to Japan, and later lived in Greece, where our first son was born (1989), then a year in Egypt, and Cyprus again until we finally settled in Luxembourg in late 1991 after my father died.


We had another son in 1994 and a daughter 2 years later. Both our sons turned out to be seriously mentally handicapped and autistic, totally unable to live independently. They inherited the fragile-X chromosome syndrome. Luckily, our daughter did not inherit any of it and is not handicapped at all.


During the late 1990s I completely turned away from the Divine Principle teachings about “God” and “True Parents”, and developed my own ideas about how we and the universe came into existence, etc., but I did not impose anything on my wife, who remains a loyal follower of Moon and now his wife. I no longer believe in the “God” postulated by the monotheistic religions at all.


I don’t hide the fact that I reject Divine Principle from leaders here in Luxembourg but nonetheless my wife and I are regarded as regular members – though I don’t participate in most church activities, including one of the most basic – prayer.

Our daughter knows I don’t believe but I let her choose her own way – though under the influence of my wife — so she has gone to several short workshops to learn DP in the Netherlands and has also been to Cheong Pyeong for 21- and 40-day workshops. It seems she fits in well and can take it all in stride without the terrible mental/spiritual struggles I went through, and also without becoming a kind of fanatic.

She studied for 5 years at Sun Moon University (the church’s own university) in Korea, which she really seemed to enjoy. She met an American fellow student and member there, whose parents contacted us because he had told them he was interested in our daughter as a matching partner. When our daughter agreed we arranged a matching with him and his parents, and they were “blessed” by Mrs. Moon in 2018.


So, somehow I am both still inside as well as outside the church – inside in a practical sense through my wife and daughter, even tithing, but outside because I don’t believe any of their teachings at all and don’t follow any instructions. Of course, it’s like a house of cards, and it could all come crashing down if my wife insisted on following a course that would go totally against my convictions.

  • Originally written March 2016. Updated May 2023.
Snow-capped mountains of Nuristan, formerly Kafiristan, beyond the Kunar Valley, Afghanistan, Oct. 1987. The setting of Rudyard Kipling’s “The Man Who Would Be King.”

ON DEATH – MY OWN …

I feel I should add part of a previous post here about my death:


Diary entry Thursday 3 September 2020 (adapted):


I’m reading an article in Psyche magazine about how to overcome our fear of death.


Do I fear death? In one sense, yes. It’s the fear of the unknown, a natural fear.


But I believe in essence I do not fear death itself – being no more. What I fear far more than anything else is the likely and the possible consequences of my death for those I leave behind – my immediate family. My wife and our children.


How could they cope when I am gone? I worry about that much more than about myself dying. Also, I worry very much that I might become a burden to them if I lose my mind or parts of my body.


This is what I fear and what I worry about much, much more than my own demise. I believe I am now fully reconciled with the idea that I will die. I certainly would not want to live too long – only long enough to be able to take care of my family as much as possible. I do want to leave this existence once I feel I have done my best in this. … And I definitely do not want to exist beyond this earthly life.


I, this self – whatever it is – clearly began at some point in time after I was conceived in my mother’s womb. I believe it is quite natural that I should cease to exist at some point in time.

Categories: Thoughts, Travel | Tags: , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Blog at WordPress.com.